Appenzell
Switzerland
A Daily Compendium
of Free-Market Thinking
The Daily Bell Newswire - It's FREE!    


News & Analysis

US Emerges From Recession

Saturday, October 31, 2009 - by Staff Report


Ben Bernanke

The world's largest economy expanded at a 3.5% annual pace in the third quarter of the year, marking the end of a recession that has cost 7.2 million American jobs and prompted the most radical Government response since the Depression of the 1930s. The figure topped the prediction of Wall Street analysts who had penciled in growth of 3.2%. The return to growth in the last quarter was driven by a rise in consumer spending and a blitz of stimulus measures by the Government. While acknowledging that the economy has rebounded, experts are divided on how strong the recovery will be. Some reckon there is a significant risk that the economy will fall back into recession. "At this stage the numbers are just going to tell you the recession is over, and now the argument is going to centre on the speed of the recovery," Chris Rupkey, chief financial economist at Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi, told Bloomberg. "There will be a lot of naysayers." The US economy, which has been the engine of world growth for the last decade, still faces significant headwinds, with President Obama's ability for further stimulus constrained by a record $1.4 trillion Budget deficit, and unemployment rising. The unemployment rate hit 9.8% last month as another 263,000 people lost their jobs. Ben Bernanke (pictured left), the chairman of the Federal Reserve, warned earlier this month that the economy probably does not yet have the momentum to reduce unemployment. However, America's official emergence from recession means that of the major G7 economies, just Britain and Italy remain mired in the downturn. France, Germany and Japan all came out of recession in the second quarter of the year and figures for the third quarter have yet to be released. - Telegraph

Dominant Social Theme: Good times return?

Free-Market Analysis: The jobless recovery has begun. We don't think it's much of a recovery, though. We guess we're among the naysayers. We've figured that in America alone the numbers of jobless (those wanting jobs anyway) are between 20 percent and 30 percent. That's over 60 million individuals that the country cannot provide jobs for. It is the outcome of a system that relies on monetary stimulation to create a series of false booms and then leaves people without work when the inevitable busts take place.

In Europe, the economic situation continues to be aggravated by joblessness and a lack of growth. Countries in Eastern Europe and some Western countries like Spain are especially hard hit. Britain and Italy are also struggling. Regardless of what statistics show, the system itself is configured in a way that promotes joblessness. So many jobs are created during a false boom that will not remain during the inevitable downturn that many people live constantly on the edge with little or nothing to fall back on should they lose work.

Additionally, the figures that governments use to calculate the "health" of the economy are often massaged and untrustworthy. While articles have trumpeted the recovery, especially in America, even mainstream articles are a good bit less enthusiastic once you get past the first couple of paragraphs. Here's an excerpt from an article that appeared on Yahoo:

The U.S. economy grew in the third quarter for the first time in more than a year as government stimulus helped lift consumer spending and home building, fueling an unexpectedly strong advance.

Signaling the end of the worst recession in 70 years, the Commerce Department on Thursday said the economy expanded at an annual rate of 3.5 percent in the July- September period, snapping four down quarters with its fastest growth pace since the third quarter of 2007 and exceeding forecasts for a 3.3 percent rate.

The report helped lift global stock markets which were also boosted by improving third-quarter corporate earnings, including higher-than-expected profits from household goods makers Procter & Gamble Co and Colgate-Palmolive Co. On Wall Street, the broad S&P 500 index of U.S. stocks had gained more than 1 percent in morning trade after four days of falls caused by investor concerns over the outlook for economic growth.

Prices for U.S. government debt and the U.S. dollar fell as traders exited safe havens."The economy has emerged with gusto from the deepest recession since World War Two," said Harm Bandholz, economist at UniCredit Markets and Investment Banking in New York. "The short-term prospects for the economy remain good."

Growth was generally broad-based with solid gains in consumer spending, exports and home construction. But, worryingly for economists, it was also driven by emergency government programs like the popular "cash for clunkers" incentive for new auto purchases and an $8,000 tax credit for first-time home buyers.

The auto discount program ended in August and the home tax credit is due to expire next month, although Congress is working on a plan to extend it.

Stripping out auto output, the economy would have expanded at only a 1.9 percent rate in the third quarter.

So it turns out that the US economy actually expanded only two percent, not three percent. But we wonder if these figures are adjusted for price inflation. And in any event, a recovery based on the kind of money stimulation that has taken place is one that has intrinsic problems. The main problem of course is when and how to withdraw funds that have been poured into the economy by central banks to try to get Western economies moving again.

If central bankers attempt to remove money from the system too soon, economies will slump and whatever growth has taken place will vanish. If central bankers wait, the result will be price-inflation that will be just as destructive to the nascent recovery, and probably moreso. Either way, a chain of events has been manufactured that will result in further problems down the road.

Conclusion: The mainstream media is trumpeting a recovery based on certain statistical growth rates. But these are only positive signs if seen in isolation. If one looks at the broader sweep of Western economic progress one can only be struck by its cyclical nature and by the deepening of the cycles as more and more monetary stimulation is seen as necessary to keep fiat money economies afloat. There is unfortunately no way out of such fiat money traps. They have an ineluctable logic about them and cycles will simply continue until they become so extreme that the system is not viable anymore. That's why we figure sooner or later there will be a return to some sort of gold and silver private money standard. In the long run, nothing else works.

Post Feedback

We look forward to hearing your feedback and will respond to you as promptly as possible. Unless you specifically request otherwise, we reserve the right to publish your comments on the Daily Bell website. Please note, harassment, vulgarity and personal attacks are not welcomed.






View Feedback

Posted by John on 10/31/2009 9:49:00 AM

Yes and if you strip out the numbers for the housing sales it was probably minus numbers not positive. Congress may indeed extend and even expand the housing credit. But at what expense to the tax payer!


Reply from the Daily Bell:

Stimulus doesn't work?

Posted by Kaydell Bowles on 10/31/2009 12:30:06 PM

The liberal media want to paint a rosy picture to advance their adgenda. Maybe that may be in the data they look at and playing with the numbers but a good look is at the unemployment which is still going up and nothing around the corner. The liberal media lies as does the President's administration.,


Reply from the Daily Bell:

Yes, what good is a recovery that continually adds more unemployed?

Posted by Ingo Bischoff on 10/31/2009 12:50:13 PM

"The main problem of course is when and how to withdraw funds that have been poured into the economy by central banks to try to get Western economies moving again."...

When the governments/central banks stimulate the economy with a $1 of debt and create productivity gain of $2, the question quoted above applies. However, when at present a $1 stimulus brings only a productivity gain of $0.88, the question is moot.

Any government stimulus now, actually sends us deeper into the hole. The financial system has entered a death spiral. All the "happy talk" about coming out of a recession is just that "happy talk".


Reply from the Daily Bell:

An interesting perspective. The stimulus may indeed be working backward.

Posted by Bowman W. Davis on 10/31/2009 2:20:56 PM

Any numbers coming from the government have created using bad math with bad intentions to generate support for more regulation, more government programs and less freedom for the citizens.


Reply from the Daily Bell:

The numbers are hard to believe.

Post Feedback

We look forward to hearing your feedback and will respond to you as promptly as possible. Unless you specifically request otherwise, we reserve the right to publish your comments on the Daily Bell website. Please note, harassment, vulgarity and personal attacks are not welcomed.








[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

News & Analysis
03/09/10 More Sovereign Defaults Loom?
03/09/10 George Soros - Secret Austrian Economist?
03/08/10 Iceland to Europe: Drop Dead
03/08/10 Gold: Best Asset of the 2000s
03/06/10 Solution to Economic Crisis - Pretty Wallpaper?
03/05/10 Toppling Memes of the Global Elite
Guest Editorials
03/08/10 Big Lie Theory Flourishes, by Dr. Tibor Machan
03/06/10 Tales of "Strong Reforms" in Iqaluit - or Possibly Just a Hoax, by Frank R. Suess
03/06/10 Property Rights and Gun Rights, by Dr. Tibor Machan

Subscribe to the
Daily Bell Newswire

It's FREE!
Timely email notification of...
  • Breaking News
  • Feature Interviews
  • Guest Editorials
  • White Papers
  • eBooks & Shorts
  • Special FREE offers
...and much much more!
Exclusive Interviews
03/07/10 Charles Payne on Business Broadcasting, Stock Picking Strategies and the Promise of Global Investing
02/28/10 Jim Rogers on China Opportunities, the Gold Standard and the Development of his Free-Market Financial Philosophy
02/21/10 Lew Rockwell on von Mises, Ron Paul, Free-Markets and the Future of Freedom
© Copyright 2008 - 2010 Appenzeller Business Press AG (ARBP). All Rights Reserved. The Daily Bell is an informative compendium of independent economic views and analysis, which is published by ARBP. The information contained in the Daily Bell is for informational purposes only, is impersonal and not tailored to the investment needs of any particular person and should not be construed as financial or investment advice. ARBP does not accept any liability or responsibility for, nor does it verify the accurateness of the information being provided in the Daily Bell. Daily Bell articles and interviews may include the contributions of several Daily Bell editors and may require factual editing after their initial post. Readers of the Daily Bell or any affiliated or linked sources or sites must accept the responsibility for performing their own due diligence before acting on any of the information provided within the report regardless of the source. In addition to proprietary, internally generated content, the Daily Bell publishes guest editorials from a selection of free-market thinkers, which may have been reprinted elsewhere and are not necessarily representative of ARBP's editorial views. Copyright is attributed to the author of any guest editorials featured at the Daily Bell, unless noted otherwise. ARBP often uses images licensed from Getty Images on the Swiss Confidential website. To unsubscribe from the Daily Bell, click here.