Appenzell
Switzerland
A Daily Compendium
of Free-Market Thinking
The Daily Bell Newswire - It's FREE!    


News & Analysis

EU Attacks British Civil Liberties

Wednesday, November 11, 2009 - by  Staff Report


EU Court

Can you imagine being tried in [Britain] for something that is not a crime here? If this sounds like something Kafka might have dreamt up, it is actually a proposal before EU interior ministers that will soon be enshrined in UK law. It is the sort of legislation that, were it going through Parliament, would be exciting a good deal of comment and debate; but because it is being promulgated in the councils of Europe, hardly anyone knows it is happening. The initiative, known as the Transfer of Criminal Proceedings, is the latest in a succession of pan-European reforms designed to speed up extradition, prosecution and conviction of criminals. You might think that is no bad thing - except that how a country organizes its system of criminal law and sanction is the very essence of nationhood. This is no longer about mutual co-operation to ensure the bad guys don't escape justice by hopping from one EU country to another; this is about putting in place the trappings of a single jurisdiction. - Telegraph

Dominant Social Theme: Consolidation is efficient?

Free-Market Analysis: Of all the things going on in the world today, the steady encroachment on civil liberties by the European Union is one of the most puzzling to decipher. It would be a little easier to understand if it were happening pre-Internet. But in fact it is happening in plain view of the world, especially the Western world - especially America - because the Internet is cataloguing every bit of the profoundly anti-democratic changes that are being made.

With the passage of the Lisbon treaty, the EU's pace regarding consolidation of Europe under one roof is picking up, though in our opinion it is no more convincing than before and presages a great deal of trouble (for the EU) ahead. At every level, we would argue, the EU is moving too fast and without proper care. It is most surprising. It illustrates, we believe, the compulsion the monetary elite seems to feel to consolidate gains in wealth and power in a post-Internet world. This is not an indication of strength, in our opinion.

What are the signs? They are obvious. The passage of the Lisbon treaty, which essentially puts in place a European constitution for the EU, was accomplished by ignoring votes against the parameters of the treaty by countries that were actually allowed to have votes, including the French, the very nation that provided much of the EU's impetus during its middle years. The Irish were the last to vote against the EU constitution-that-is-not-a-constitution (but is a treaty). They voted no, so the leaders of the EU basically told the leaders of Ireland (pro EU as almost all politicians are) that citizens would have to vote again. So they did. Then the EU poured an ocean of euros into Ireland and basically bought off anything that might conceivably pull a lever against Lisbon. This plus the recent collapse of the Irish economy was enough to make the difference. The Irish voted "yes" and the EU transformed from an economic partnership into a full-fledged nation state. This is the stuff that ends up in history books under "can you believe that." Or "thank goodness we didn't live then."

The point of all this is that the EU is not a corpus that came into being voluntarily. It has been erected through tactics that are questionable at the least and obviously illegitimate in any case. And every illegitimate action has been documented electronically. There is a problem with all this. It is not the illegitimate actions per se. It is something worse, that lies at the very core of the EU.

It used to be that nations were conquered by the sword, but even then the conqueror usually had some sort of pan-national justification for his actions. When Charlemagne consolidated Europe, he did it under the banner of the Holy Roman Church - his actions were conducted for the greater glory of God and the church. But what is the EU's rationale? Perhaps it is socialism, but the religion of socialism is supposed to be welcomed by "the people" - and the EU isn't especially welcomed by anyone these days. The EU, in other words, is bereft of an animating purpose, has been erected illegally and is now taking steps to consolidate a power base that its leaders amassed without creating an over-arching justification.

The EU lacks a DOMINANT SOCIAL THEME. This is significant not because it illustrates a fundamental lacunae (it does) but because it shows, in our humble opinion, just how panicked the monetary elite really is. The elite tends to work generationally, and if one looks at the ongoing attempts to consolidate nation-states into a global entity (the apparent and putative goal, events would seem to show), the pace is slow and is usually laid-out with care.

After the American War Between the States (which basically put to rest much of the American Republic), the idea that the war was fought over slavery became the dominant social theme. The First World War never had much of a theme, but the Second World War's dominant social theme soon became obvious and powerful. Every schoolchild knows it - that Britain and then, especially, America, saved the world from the Hitler. (This ignores, of course, the support Hitler had to begin with from both Britain and America, and the foundational aspects of the Reich, which were laid directly after World War One in a series of Draconian treaties.)

The dominant social theme provided by the monetary elite (for it was indeed the monetary elite of Europe and America that triggered the EU to begin with) was that the EU, by creating a common European market, would ensure that what happened previously in Europe would "never happen again." But this dominant social theme no longer holds sway now that the EU is so much more than a common market. It is a nation state of its own, encompassing a vast number of additional nation states.

Conclusion: We return to conclusions voiced in previous iterations of the Bell. Those leading the EU are taking a very big gamble. No sociopolitical power of this size has ever been erected so swiftly, absent violence. And it is taking place in a Europe that seems tranquil on the surface but is actually a seething hotbed of tribal loyalties and ancient cultures that go back in some cases to nearly the Stone Age. Without an animating dominant social theme in place, with the Internet cataloguing virtually every aspect of the EU's illegitimate actions, we begin to get a feeling that the elite steering the ship has left it on autopilot. There is no plan B. Just consolidate with maximum haste. Unless this course is modified, we have to believe this latest experiment in a greater Europe will end in tears, and worse.

Post Feedback

We look forward to hearing your feedback and will respond to you as promptly as possible. Unless you specifically request otherwise, we reserve the right to publish your comments on the Daily Bell website. Please note, harassment, vulgarity and personal attacks are not welcomed.






View Feedback

Posted by WAYNE on 11/11/2009 12:44:58 AM

Frightening, isn't it? And yes, the internet is revealing this at every turn. But remember, slaves don't want, and value freedom.The majority have been conditioned to dismiss non- mainstream news sources as kooks, and conspiracy theorists.

We'll all on our own now! There are no free societies left on this planet, just free individuals. Re-read your Harry Browne for strategies for the individual.

The creative stock that built the UK and the USA are all dead now, and this is the generation that will go into slavery. It's all cyclical, and no individual can stop the march of cycles!


Reply from the Daily Bell:

Ah, a pessimist.

Posted by Ernest Kroll on 11/11/2009 8:33:00 AM

What an exciting world we live in! If it's not one thing, it's another - and it seems that it gets wilder and wilder. Note that I didn't say 'better.'

Maybe it'll start getting better (in America, at least) after the coming elections. Don't lose sight that important socio-political movements in Europe have a direct impact on America (and Canada?) And we mustn't forget that Obama & Company is desperately trying to pound the round peg of America into the square hole of the European mold.

Obama & Company is emulating the late and great President FDR who took great advantage of crisis after crisis in the 1930's to implement one socialist program after another. FDR was great in that he almost personally orchestrated our avoidance of anarchy during the Great Depression, and the victory of the Allies in WW2.

The greatest differences between FDR and BHO are that FDR was experienced and qualified for Presidential leadership, and that he did not lie to the American people. What you saw was what you got. In Obama's case he lied to us repeatedly, and what we saw is not what we are getting. Although FDR's policies to defeat the Great Depression may well have averted national anarchy, they have had long-lasting negative effects -- in this BHO emulates FDR.

FDR was at once the great builder and the great destroyer ... and BHO's mentor. If the coming elections repudiate Obama's rise to power, it remains to be seen if it is possible to rescind the damage inflicted by the actions of Obama & Company, and the stupid generation that put him and his cohorts there.


Reply from the Daily Bell:

We don't share your enthusiasm for FDR, but Barack Obama certainly has plenty of problems now, many self-inflicted.

Posted by Ernest Kroll on 11/11/2009 9:37:03 AM

In my last post I did not mean to sound like an FDR supporter. As I said, FDR's policies were both good and bad for America, with the bad probably outweighing the good. He proved to be a great wartime president which cannot be downplayed. His CCC program was extremely beneficial for both the participants and for our country. On the other hand his Social Security program was exactly the opposite. These are only a few of the many pros and cons of his tenure as president. It is obvious that BHO is emulating FDR's success as a manipulative politician. We can only hope that Congress will be successful in stopping or at least blunting BHO's efforts at socialization, and the castigation of our country on the altar of political correctness.


Reply from the Daily Bell:

Thanks for the follow up. You certainly seem correct about how the current US president is positioning himself via FDR's legacy as mainstream history has written it.

Posted by Bowman W. Davis on 11/11/2009 10:28:31 AM

The monied elite have gained their power and enacted their systematic dismantling of everything sovereign to the individual countries of Eurpoe, not by force, but by the acquesience of its citizens. They no longer care about,nor want individual freedoms. They have lost and will continue to lose because they have no will nor desire to win. They crave to be wards of the government state. The same is true of America. If freedom is to survive, it will be saved by a minority of the population and not by re-electing crooked politicians.


Reply from the Daily Bell:

It is always a remnant that makes a difference, isn't it?

Posted by James Russell Downey on 11/11/2009 7:58:17 PM

As usual, the EU is another example of seller a lesser idea to the masses and then, within a decade, the jackboots start clicking. Here in America we call it a slippery slope. We are already racing down it with our FED.


Reply from the Daily Bell:

Seems so.

Post Feedback

We look forward to hearing your feedback and will respond to you as promptly as possible. Unless you specifically request otherwise, we reserve the right to publish your comments on the Daily Bell website. Please note, harassment, vulgarity and personal attacks are not welcomed.








[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

News & Analysis
03/12/10 American Investors Shun Stocks?
03/12/10 Elite Retreat? McCain Drops Diet Bill
03/11/10 The Desperation of Quantitative Easing
03/11/10 One U.S. Soldier's Struggle to Reintegrate
03/10/10 Gold is Toppy, Buy More?
03/10/10 Internet Icon Marc Andreessen: Burn Old Media Model
Guest Editorials
03/10/10 Is Quality Health Care a Fundamental Right? by Dr. Tibor Machan
03/08/10 Big Lie Theory Flourishes, by Dr. Tibor Machan
03/06/10 Tales of "Strong Reforms" in Iqaluit - or Possibly Just a Hoax, by Frank R. Suess

Subscribe to the
Daily Bell Newswire

It's FREE!
Timely email notification of...
  • Breaking News
  • Feature Interviews
  • Guest Editorials
  • White Papers
  • eBooks & Shorts
  • Special FREE offers
...and much much more!
Exclusive Interviews
03/07/10 Charles Payne on Business Broadcasting, Stock Picking Strategies and the Promise of Global Investing
02/28/10 Jim Rogers on China Opportunities, the Gold Standard and the Development of his Free-Market Financial Philosophy
02/21/10 Lew Rockwell on von Mises, Ron Paul, Free-Markets and the Future of Freedom
© Copyright 2008 - 2010 Appenzeller Business Press AG (ARBP). All Rights Reserved. The Daily Bell is an informative compendium of independent economic views and analysis, which is published by ARBP. The information contained in the Daily Bell is for informational purposes only, is impersonal and not tailored to the investment needs of any particular person and should not be construed as financial or investment advice. ARBP does not accept any liability or responsibility for, nor does it verify the accurateness of the information being provided in the Daily Bell. Daily Bell articles and interviews may include the contributions of several Daily Bell editors and may require factual editing after their initial post. Readers of the Daily Bell or any affiliated or linked sources or sites must accept the responsibility for performing their own due diligence before acting on any of the information provided within the report regardless of the source. In addition to proprietary, internally generated content, the Daily Bell publishes guest editorials from a selection of free-market thinkers, which may have been reprinted elsewhere and are not necessarily representative of ARBP's editorial views. Copyright is attributed to the author of any guest editorials featured at the Daily Bell, unless noted otherwise. ARBP often uses images licensed from Getty Images on the Swiss Confidential website. To unsubscribe from the Daily Bell, click here.