The Daily Bell Newswire – It's Free!

News & Analysis

EU Will Fail Upwards Until it Really Fails

Thursday, February 11, 2010 – by Staff Report

This week's summit of EU leaders in Brussels rapidly evolves from a policy workshop into an historic gathering that may catapult the EU across the Rubicon towards fiscal federalism and a de facto debt union. The EU's top brass are seizing on the crisis to push for a radical extension of EU powers, saying Greece has exposed the deep flaws in the structure of monetary union. Herman Van Rompuy, the EU's new president, has submitted a text calling for the creation of an "economic government" that shifts responsibility for economic planning from national authorities to the "EU level". In a parallel move, Commission chief Jose Barroso said Brussels has treaty powers allowing it to take the reins of economic management. " This is a time for boldness. I believe that our economic and social situation demands a radical shift from the status quo. And the new Lisbon Treaty allows this," he said. – UK Telegraph

Dominant Social Theme: Having failed, the EU must acquire more powers.

Free-Market Analysis: The European Union, like Frankenstein's monster, is not about to die again – or not if its leaders can help it. Every crisis, every mis-step, every unworkable solution only provides those running the EU with additional reasons why the EU should obtain more power. It is a classic case of failing upward, and a cynical one as there is ample evidence that those who founded the EU always expected that serial crises would present themselves as an opportunity to create an ever-closer union.

Now, as the Greek dilemma presents itself, we can see from the point of view of the EU that the problems of Greece provide ample justification for the creation of a far more powerful EU entity, one that includes "economic government." Presumably what this means is that any serious governmental actions regarding a member nation's finance would have to be vetted and approved by EU higher-ups. Not only that, but the EU commissioners such as Barroso are already mustering the argument that they have the authority to take over due to the "new Lisbon Treaty."

The Lisbon Treaty is actually the warmed-over remnants of the massively authoritarian constitution that EU bigwigs tried to ram down the collective throat of the EU – a fraud so evident and repulsive that even the citizens of France voted against it (though one of their own politicos, Giscard d'Estaing, was its main author.) The problem with the EU is in fact the problem with its former constitution – the rights that citizens have are provided by the state and may be redefined by the state or taken away altogether as the bureaucracy sees fit. Contrast this to the US Constitution, which clearly states that citizens' rights are ordained by a creator and cannot be redefined or removed. (Of course they have been, but not legally so.)

The American Constitution is a fairly abbreviated document providing a clear (if general) statement about the powers of the Federal government (only the powers stated IN the Constitution are available to the US FedGov) whereas the EU constitution – not adopted – is an abysmally bloated and rhetorically bankrupt document, every word of which reveals the crookedness of the minds and motives of those who wrote it. And yet, like Mary Shelley's undead monster, the EU continues to expand, as its major players scramble to support the union no matter the cost. Here's some more from the article:

Michael Meister, parliamentary chief for Germany's Christian Democrats, said the crisis could not be allowed to drag on. "Our top priority is the stability of the euro," he told FT Deutschland. "Should Greece receive help, it will only be under tough conditions and if the Greek government undertakes root-and-branch reforms."

Germany's apparent backing for a bail-out comes despite worries that it will lead to the breakdown of fiscal discipline across the Club Med region. It also raises troubling questions of fairness. Ireland has tackled its own crisis by slashing wages and going far beyond any measure so far offered by Greece, yet Dublin has not received help.

Germany's dramatic shift in policy changes the character of the euro project. It follows weeks of soul-searching in Berlin, and after increasingly loud pleas from Brussels, Paris and southern capitals. The deciding factor was concern that letting Greece fail risked a "Lehman-style" run on Club Med debt, with systemic spill-over across Europe.

Greece and a number of other "weaker" countries joined the EU even though their governments were spending too much, to the point where trends hinted at eventually unmanageable debt loads and thus default. We recently read a fascinating portrayal about how EU funds, meant to support Greek economic expansion were simply funneled off into private accounts. The marinas, land-based infrastructure and other elements of an expanded Greek economy were contracted for but never built. And thus what was on the surface supposed to be a methodology supporting Greek expansion turned into what can only be characterized as a series of bribes.

Of course Greece joined the EU – the power structure of the country, its biggest construction and tourist businesses, along with the political class, would likely have done almost anything to get their collective hands on so much free dough. And we have to assume that this animating feature of Greek cooperation is a mechanism that was repeated over and over with many other EU countries.

Those orchestrating the steady expansion of the European Union seem confident that serial crises will continue to consolidate power at the federal level. But when we look closely at how this will work, we end up with the idea that first Greece and then many other of the weaker countries in the EU are doomed to a kind of grinding and endless cycle of budget cuts and rate increases that will make it difficult for a vibrant economy to emerge for any length of time.

Greece, Spain and many other countries of the EU therefore seem destined to experience the worst that federal control of money and economic power has to offer. Some kinds of government will be substantially trimmed back, but massive government programs, in all their corruption and waste, will remain. The central banking system will remain in place, with all the ruin that proposes, but rates will rise to a point that they will not be affordable except for larger corporate entities. Gray and black markets may flourish as the economic picture gets more and more distorted.

All of this is expectable and will likely occur. But we think once the reality of what the EU is becoming is clarified by an endless, grinding recession/depression, the citizens of many of the weaker EU states will simply decide that they will not participate anymore. The trigger will be the bad times, but the information that puts it into perspective will be provided by the Internet – which must certainly be more and more ubiquitous in Europe as it is in America. And, yes, this phenomenon is already observable in the States. The information on the corruption and malfeasance of the system has been available on the ‘Net for years, but it took a poor economic environment to concentrate people's minds and make the information relevant.

Because of our focus on the Internet as a modern-day Gutenberg press, the Daily Bell remains one of a few publications predicting with some confidence that eventually there will be vast changes in the economic and legislative environment of the United States. We believe this will occur as citizens fully understand the ramifications of the money system and security apparatus that has grown up around them in the past 100 years. We believe the same process will take place in the EU – especially as the EU is less rooted than the American system.

Conclusion: We have suggested that readers hold at least some physical gold and silver as a result of potential monetary upheaval, but the ramifications of what may occur will likely touch aspects of people's lives beyond the economic ones. When we look at the pace of change, it seems to us that the power elite is beginning to struggle and that it is gradually losing control of the rhetoric and various foundational mechanisms that previously gave society its cohesion. We don't think this is a bad thing by the way. We could, in fact, compare it to Narnia in some aspects, after the long winter when the land began to bloom once more and the Lion roared.




Latest Daily Bell Articles

Feedback

Effective April 25, 2012, the Daily Bell will discontinue allowing feedback comments. We have left in place the large body of responses posted in the past, as we appreciate the valuable contributions made by some of our readers.
Showing 1 - 11 of 11 - Newest on top - Reorder Feedback
  Posted by Simon - South Africa on 02/13/10 04:47 AM

As I understand it the Bell believes that the EU is a 'German' enterprise, in the sense that Germany is a source for much of the EU decision making and momentum. I have copied the two paragraphs below from an article by Tom Sunic in the Occidental Observer:

Click to view link

It would be great to hear the bells take. It would also be great if the bell could interview Doctor Sunic.

"The dominant idea behind the creation of the European Union was to keep Germany harnessed while tapping into its Prussian work ethic and financial largesse. One-third of the EU budget tab is footed by German taxpayers. Seen from perspective of international law, Germany is still at war with the Allies. It is certainly no accident that, unlike any other member state in the European Union, including the other big two, the UK and France, Germany has no privilege of holding a referendum when rejecting or endorsing EU treaties.

"Germany has no choice but to accept the decisions of the European Commission, with the obligatory nodding of its nondescript parliament, the Bundestag. On the institutional level the European Union is shaped very much like the multi-ethnic former Soviet Union or ex-Yugoslavia. European Parliament apparatchiks, whose number has skyrocketed to 736 deputies, all of them paid about $120,000/year and enjoying a multitude of perks, are proportionally elected according to the size of their countries. The EU Parliament resembles the Supreme Soviet, while its powerful 27-member executive body known as the European Commission, mirrors the former Soviet Politburo."

Reply from The Daily Bell

We would have to believe the truth lies somewhere in the middle. Obviously, France and the Anglo-American axis sought to restrain Germany through entangling it in a larger alliance. At the same time, as the largest, most powerful player, Germany ends up in at least partial control of the EU and is able to a degree to affect its destiny and shape its future. Thus, for the elites of the EU and Germany, the union offers multiple benefits ... probably one of the reasons that it has continued forward despite its evident shabbiness, dysfunction and enlarging corruption."

We will look into the availability of Doctor Sunic.

  Posted by Shawn on 02/11/10 09:17 PM

The plan is still working and crises are opportunities.

I just read that 60 of Demarcates in the USA believe that Socialism is a good thing.

Does freedom have a chance?

Reply from The Daily Bell

Why not?

  Posted by Bowman on 02/11/10 08:04 PM

A very good and insightful look at the inner, souless workings of the EU.However, It is my belief the citizens of most member states comprising the EU, will not demand accountability or less Statism or more liberty, but, will in fact accept it with not much else than token civil disobedience.

Most Europeans (with a couple of exceptions) have never known true liberty or free market government or economic policies. It seems the Europeans have no appetite for anything other than radical socialism, and if this is true, there can be very little improvement in an ever worsening condition, in the political as well as the economic.

  Posted by Gordon Gray on 02/11/10 07:54 PM

Does anyone remember this gem from Jean-Monnet the so called EU father? "Europes nations should be guided towards the super state without their people understanding what is happening.

This can be accomplished by successive steps each disguised as having an economic purpose but which will inevitably and irreversibly lead to "FEDERATION". Its about time the Europeans woke up to this fraud and started to determine their own futures before its too late.

Reply from The Daily Bell

Maybe the Internet will help.

  Posted by Lance E. Schultz on 02/11/10 03:04 PM

America will soon learn our beloved Fed and all CB's around the horn are all borne of the same Idumean blood. Our great national pride; our infamous beloved Dollar $ of Midas will soon be engulfed in flames along with the Pound Sterling and our nations and our sovereignty will evaporate as the dew of hermon.

There will be nothing but blood in the streets. And from then shall come a great emancipator who will offer unity, peace, stability in our great time of suffering and need. And his name will still be "little known."

But he will be proffered as an "impressive," "clever" and "calm" man having experienced and as a budget hard-liner delivered his own people from the ravages of profligate debt. And he will extend that hand and offer his "moderate" and "fair minded" rebukes to our shamed lifeless leaders and as duly expected our peoples will likewise extend their hands to have them bound permanently in the shroud of his newfound system of global unity, global security, global prosperity and global peace.

What else should we expect from such a modest, soft spoken, unassuming a man as this. What have we to fear from such a man as this? What have we to fear from such a system when our own "system" lay dying in ash heaps all around us? How could we fear this man whose fondness and love for penning Haiku and poetry have inspired his great works?

What fear can be found in such a man as makes annual pilgrimage retreats to the ancient monastery of Affligem Abbey? Oh please dismiss his brief occasion to have worked for this same raucous bunch in his own nation's central bank. What's a poor Jesuit educated economist to do for a living? After all, there's not much a market for a philosophy degree in Brussels is there? It's good time fellowcraft to read his six work treatise on all things politic and economic to get a glimpse in to what awaits you with baited breath. Holcombes fear raiseth the hair on the neck but the fear which is to come raiseth the hair on the soul.

Reply from The Daily Bell

Thanks for the interesting feedback.

  Posted by TMoore on 02/11/10 02:50 PM

Fie! Fie upon't! The comparison of the EU Frankenstein to our Constitution rings true in the hearts of freemen. Sadly, John Adams prophetically proclaimed that our Constitution was fit only for a moral and religious people. It is not clear that we are either of those things...

  Posted by GKS on 02/11/10 01:59 PM

The EU is a conglomeration of widely divergent states most old enemies that can barely run there own country not a whole continent. In the Bible Read book of Daniel God definitely says Europe will not be one nation but part clay part iron (ie; weak and broken up)Have doubts? then go back to year oneAD from 2nd world war and count the times joining has failed .The EU will also.And thats GOOD.

  Posted by Ryan on 02/11/10 11:29 AM

The usual suspects.
How Goldman Sachs Helped Greece to Mask its True Debt

Click to view link,1518,676634,00.html

  Posted by B. DeVane on 02/11/10 08:55 AM

Our leaders definitely are not blind as to the injuries they cause their people. We do exactly as they know we will ... they strangle us, and then we cry for more! After all, they know what is best for us.

  Posted by Puzzled on 02/11/10 07:20 AM

Thank you, once again! You have confirmed my suspicions about The Euro and that mess they call European Union. It seems we have one master, for we are all traveling the same road to destruction. How is it our leaders can be so blind to what injury they cause our peoples? Puzzled

Reply from The Daily Bell

Maybe they are not blind?

  Posted by Peterson on 02/11/10 06:12 AM

It's failing upwards right now but it will soon fail downwards.