Editorials

Testimonials
  • FANTASTIC SOURCE

    The Daily Bell is a fantastic source of challenging thought from a wide range of freedom loving people.

    Dr. Joel Wade
    Author, Psychotherapist and Life Coach

  • READ IT EVERY DAY

    A defender of free markets, The Daily Bell takes a libertarian approach to expose and unravel global misinformation. Read The Daily Bell – every day!

    Charles Payne
    FOX Business Analyst

  • GREAT JOB, DAILY BELL

    I can say that, unlike the mainstream press, The Daily Bell knows the questions to ask and has the chutzpah to ask them. They realize that socialism and Keynesianism are wrecking the world and they are helping to save what is left of liberty and free markets.

    Richard J. Maybury
    Author, Editor of U.S. & World Early Warning Report

  • CUTTING EDGE ANALYSIS

    At a time when growing majorities worldwide are tuning out mainstream news, people are seeking the cutting edge, insightful and thought provoking analysis that The Daily Bell consistently provides.

    Gerald Celente
    Bestselling Author, Founder of the Trends Research Institute

  • EXCELLENT ANALYSIS

    The Daily Bell has a great libertarian point of view, and excellent economic analysis. Add it to your daily reading.

    Peter Schiff
    Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Euro Pacific Capital

  • PROFOUND AND PROVOCATIVE

    Every day, I rely on the Daily Bell for a different perspective you'll never find in the regular media. It's an analysis and timely insight that is profound and provocative.

    Craig Huey
    Author, Small Business Owner

  • OUT OF THE DARK

    The Daily Bell leads us out of the dark tunnel of manipulated press into the light of free press.

    John Perkins
    Bestselling Author

  • SEPARATES WHEAT FROM CHAFF

    The Daily Bell is a true beacon to lead in helping the reader to separate the wheat from the chaff.

    Dr. Antal Fekete
    Author, Educator and Monetary Scientist

  • INDEPENDENT

    Get outside the box with The Daily Bell and experience independent views.

    Paul Craig Roberts
    Author, Former Assistant Secretary of the Treasury in the Reagan Administration

  • VOICE OF REASON

    I have thoroughly enjoyed the analysis and interviews at The Daily Bell, which has so often been a voice of reason during these perilous times

    Dr. Thomas Woods Jr.
    NY Times Bestselling Author & Senior Fellow, Mises Institute

  • VERY INFORMATIVE

    I read The Daily Bell every day and I find it very informative.

    Marc Faber
    Dr. Marc Faber, Author, Publisher of The Gloom Boom & Doom Report

  • THOUGHTFUL NEWS, EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEWS

    I always read the Bell. The news items are thoughtfully selected, and the interviews are unavailable elsewhere.

    Doug Casey
    Bestselling Author and Founder of Casey Research Group

  • ESSENTIAL READING

    Liberty is under assault by Big Government. The Daily Bell is an essential tool for information for those who want to fight for freedom.

    Steve Forbes
    Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Forbes Media

  • COURAGEOUS REPORTING

    There is no other publication in print or on the Internet like The Daily Bell. They have the courage to report the truth and analyze current foreign policy, politics and economic events in the context of a formerly hidden history of financial elites.

    Ron Holland
    Author & Monetary Analyst

  • INTELLECTUAL JOLT

    Sit down to read from The Daily Bell and experience a jolt of intellectual energy.

    Dr. Nathaniel Branden
    Psychotherapist, Bestselling Author

  • EXCELLENT RESEARCH

    I really enjoy reading The Daily Bell for the excellent research and content provided on a wide variety of issues vital to the Freedom Movement.

    Dr. Mark Skousen
    Author & Founder of FreedomFest

  • INSIGHT YOU CANNOT IGNORE

    The Daily Bell provides unique insights on contemporary political, economic and social problems that can be found in such a concentrated form nowhere else. Whether one agrees or disagrees with it, one cannot afford to ignore it.

    Dr. Edwin Vieira
    Author and Constitutional Expert

  • PREMIER FREE-MARKET ANALYSIS

    The Daily Bell rings out for liberty every day. It is the premier online source for insightful and hard-hitting free-market analysis and interpretation of economic, political and business events.

    Dr. Richard Ebeling
    Author, Professor of Economics at Northwood University

  • INDISPENSABLE INFORMATION

    The Daily Bell is an indispensable source of news and information for those seeking to curtail the power of the welfare-warfare state.

    Dr. Grant Havers
    Chair, Department of Philosophy, Trinity Western University

  • REFRESHING

    I enjoy reading The Daily Bell because it often has refreshing and novel ways of looking at things.

    Bill Bonner
    Bestselling Author, Founder of Agora Publishing

  • MESSAGES OF TRUTH

    The Daily Bell website is one of the authentic voices cutting through the clouds of vapid opinion, the morass of mediocre media and the confusion of Orwellian doublespeak. The Bell website lives up to its name, ringing unheard messages of truth in our ears.

    Jeffrey Armstrong
    Award-winning Author, Vedic Philosopher

  • RECOMMENDED READING

    For alternative views on contemporary politics, culture and science, from a libertarian point of view, check out The Daily Bell.

    Michael A. Cremo
    Author, Vedic Archeologist

  • SOURCES YOU CAN TRUST

    The Daily Bell should be on everyone's shortlist of news sources you can trust. It's on mine, and we often refer to it in our own weekly news service at The Reality Zone.

    G. Edward Griffin
    Author, Founder of Freedom Force International

  • GREAT THINKERS YOU CAN'T GET ANYWHERE ELSE

    The Daily Bell has revived that great old institution of the personal interview, extracting information from today's great thinkers you can't get anywhere else. Outstanding!

    Jeffrey Tucker
    Author, Executive Editor of Laissez Faire Books

  • CONSISTENTLY SOLID

    The Daily Bell features consistently solid analysis of and thoughtful challenges to contemporary statism. I am proud to be on the team.

    Dr. Tibor Machan
    Author and Philosopher

  • A VIRTUAL WHO'S WHO

    The good and the bad, the big dogs and the small, the thinkers and the doers among libertarians and on the "Right" – you can encounter them all in The Daily Bell's exclusive weekly interviews. Indispensable.

    Dr. Hans Herman-Hoppe
    Author, Economist and Libertarian Philosopher

  • EXCELLENT PERSPECTIVE

    The Daily Bell affords an excellent alternative perspective on some of the noise and nonsense of mainstream media. In particular, I enjoy reading Anthony Wile's 'free-market analysis' on current subjects and articles. Very insightful.

    Frank R. Suess
    Chairman & CEO of BFI Capital Group Inc.

  • PART OF MY DAILY NEWS DIET

    I read it every day!

    Jim Rogers
    Bestselling Author, Co-founder of the Quantum Fund

  • AWE INSPIRING

    The Daily Bell is one of the most innovative and in-depth websites on the Internet. The breadth of the content is awe inspiring and the amount of knowledge imparted is almost impossible to quantify. For me, as a liberty minded seeker of knowledge, it is a must read.

    Jeff Berwick
    Founder of DollarVigilante.com

  • GUTS, OBJECTIVITY, WISDOM

    Rarely does a publication have the guts and objectivity to tell it like it is, yet the eloquence and wisdom to listen carefully to the ‘other side.’ This is The Daily Bell accomplishing its daily mission.

    James Jaeger
    Telly Award-winning Filmmaker

  • INFORMATIVE SOURCE OF INFORMATION

    The Daily Bell is an informative source of information and commentary from leading figures in the liberty movement. It's a pleasure to be interviewed alongside far more notable individuals.

    Alexander McCobin
    Executive Director of Students for Liberty

  • THE DAILY BELL IS A MUST-READ

    Because the world is changing so rapidly, it is difficult to keep up, which means The Daily Bell is a must read. I consider the information critically important reading.

    Dave Morgan
    Author, Editor of Silver-Investor.com

  • SIMPLY TERRIFIC

    The Daily Bell does a remarkable job of exposing how money power uses central banking to crush people into submission via global government with economic and political slavery being the desired end result.

    John Browne
    Former Secretary of the Conservative Defense and Finance Committees, UK Parliament

  • TRUTH AT WORK

    There are very few publications out there that have the smarts and guts to tell the truth about the dictatorial forces at work destroying our civilization. Thankfully The Daily Bell is one of them, and it appears in the mailbox every day.

    Nelson Hultberg
    Author, Director of Americans for a Free Republic

  • GREAT INVESTMENT INFORMATION

    I love reading The Daily Bell! Interesting investment information, a political and social viewpoint that lets me know I'm not alone in the world and "annotated" with analysis. I highly recommend it to all interested readers.

    Rick Rule
    Founder of Global Resource Investments Inc.

  • AHEAD OF THE CURVE

    The Daily Bell has come out of nowhere to introduce to the Internet community some of the most intriguing and proactive interviews there are out there. Let's hear it for creativity and being ahead of the curve.

    Bill Murphy
    Chairman of Gold Anti-Trust Action Committee

  • POWERFUL INSIGHTS

    I consider The Daily Bell essential reading for anyone desirous of understanding the way the world really works.

    Lord William Rees-Mogg
    Author, Former Deputy Editor, Financial Times

  • NEVER MISS AN ISSUE

    I love the Daily Bell. Every issue is principled and informative.

    Lew Rockwell
    Founder of the Mises Institute

  • A LEADING LIGHT

    The future is created by the people who build it, not the people who predict it will not exist. You can meet lots of important builders by reading The Daily Bell.

    Catherine Austin Fitts
    Former Assistant Secretary of Housing and Federal Housing Commissioner

  • A MUST-READ FOR EVERYONE

    The Daily Bell is a must-read for anyone who wants to understand the effects of the state on our economic future.

    Dr. Thomas DiLorenzo
    Professor of Economics, Loyola University Maryland

 

Subscribe now to start your FREE email subscription to:

The Daily Bell Newswire

By subscribing, I confirm that I have read the privacy policy and the terms of use policy in its entirety and I understand and accept these terms.

 


Wendy McElroy

 
Your Silence Confesses Your Guilt

Editorial By Wendy McElroy

On June 17, 2013, the United States Supreme Court (SCOTUS) further eroded one of the most potent protections Americans had against unfettered authority: the right to remain silent. In Salinas v. Texas, SCOTUS ruled that a defendant's refusal to answer police questions before his arrest and before being Mirandized could be admitted into court as substantive evidence of his guilt. If such a defendant did not explicitly invoke the Fifth Amendment, then he had effectively waived it.

Last week, the California Supreme Court expanded the SCOTUS precedent. It restored a 2007 vehicular manslaughter conviction that had been reversed by a lower court. The original conviction had been appealed on the grounds that the defendant's silence was introduced as evidence against him. The 'damning' silence was not a refusal to answer police questions. Rather, at the scene of the car crash, the defendant had not inquired about the welfare of those in the other vehicle. This, the prosecutor argued, was proof of his guilt. The jury agreed.

There are many reasons to remain silent when confronted by the police or by a legally precarious situation. For one, lawyers and legal sites strongly advise people to do so. Even totally innocent people can incriminate themselves by making confused statements. Now both silence and words could become evidence of guilt.

History offers a glimpse into why certain rights came into prominence and what life might resemble without them.

A History of "Taking the Fifth"

The Fifth Amendment to the Constitution reads, "No person... shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself." The clause came from the Virginia Declaration of Rights (1776) as drafted by George Mason. Mason, along with James Madison, is often viewed as the father of the Bill of Rights, which reined in the power of the federal government vis-a-vis individuals. Procedural rights of an accused were of particular concern because Mason was well aware of abuses committed by English courts, both ongoing and in the past. Well read in the literature surrounding those abuses, Mason insisted the rights of men take priority over the privileges of power.

The legal protection against self-incrimination was a response to England's history of forcing information and confessions through torture. The practice came into prominence when Henry VIII denied papal authority over England (1534) and established the Church of England with himself at the head. The new church retained most of the trappings of Catholicism, and Protestants became especially vulnerable to arrest for heresy.

The Protestant John Lambert became the first Englishman known to proclaim his right against self-incrimination. During his 1538 trial for heresy before an ecclesiastical court, Lambert claimed compelling a man to accuse himself violated the will of God and common law. He informed the court that he would be "more than twice a fool to show" his heresy "for it is written in your own [common] law, No man is bound to betray himself." Lambert' was responding to the practice of requiring a defendant to answer questions without revealing the charges against him. Thus, a defendant could be trapped into admitting a crime and forced to name other heretics. Silence was deemed a confession. Lambert was burned at the stake.

In 1563, the Protestant John Foxe published the Actes and Monuments, which is commonly known as Foxe's Book of Martyrs. The history of Protestant suffering under the Catholic Church became wildly popular and was reportedly second only to the Bible in England during the 16th and 17th centuries. The book urged people to demand procedural rights against authority, including the right to remain silent.

In 1590, the Puritan John Udall was accused of penning objectionable religious tracts and questioned by the secretive Court of the Star Chamber. When asked about the tracts, Udall replied, "If I were the author, I think that by law I need not answer." He claimed that self-incrimination "did not comport with [the] Magna Carta." Charged with sedition, Udall became the first defendant in a common-law trial to declare his right to remain silent. He died in prison.

The 17th century Levellers undoubtedly exerted the most influence on the Founding Fathers on this issue. In his two-volume work, An Austrian Perspective on the History of Economic Thought (1995), Murray Rothbard described the Levellers as "the world's first self-consciously libertarian movement.... [T]he Levellers led by John Lilburne, Richard Overton and William Walwyn worked out a remarkably consistent libertarian doctrine." Part of the consistency was the right to remain silent. A petition to Parliament written by the Levellers called for freeing "all men from being examined against themselves, and from being questioned or punished for doing that against which no law hath been provided."

Lilburne was called before the Court of the Star Chamber in 1637 for the crime of circulating Puritan literature. When asked how he pled, Lilburne refused to take an oath or answer incriminating questions. Instead, he appealed to his "freeborn right" to be justly tried; he became widely known as "Freeborn John." Lilburne was fined, whipped, pilloried and sentenced to prison. While there, he wrote an account of his treatment entitled The Work of the Beast. Lilburne and the book are largely credited for the closure of the Star Chamber in 1641 and for the establishment of the right to remain silent in religious courts. He then fought for procedural rights in common law ones.

In 1646, the Levellers published "An Agreement of the Free People of England. Tendered as a Peace-Offering to this distressed Nation." Their manifesto for the reform of civil rights prominently included the right against self-incrimination. In the section headed "We agree and Declare," the first item listed is "it shall not be in the power of any Representative, to punish, or cause to be punished, any person or persons for refusing to answer questions against themselves in Criminall cases." If the language of "An Agreement of the Free People" seems familiar, it is because Mason and other Founding Fathers were well aware of it.

After all, Puritans who fled to the New World carried the Levellers' ideals and works with them.

Significance of the Right to Remain Silent

The right to remain silent is at the core of American due process. It is historically anchored in the quest for religious freedom that was instrumental in founding America. It served as the strongest single protection against the use of torture by state authorities.

Today, security is said to trump liberty. Due process guarantees are often viewed as obstacles to security because they shackle authorities who are allegedly hunting terrorists and the like. It is true that due process occasionally protects the guilty. But what it always protects are average people who would otherwise be targets for the exercise of arbitrary power.

The great wrongs of history, such as religious persecution, gave rise to solutions that preserved human rights and dignity. Forgotten history repeats itself. Forgotten wrongs do so as well. The right against self-incrimination arose as a protection against the use of torture to compel confessions. Without a suspect's right to silence, the authorities have the privilege of making him speak. That could be the next logical step in the utter erosion of this indispensable protection.

Rate this article:

Total Ratings: 48 - Average Rating: 4.6

Books by Anthony Wile
Financial
Freedom

The High Alert Way to Discover Winning and Profitable Investment Ideas

Free Download

The Best of
Anthony Wile

Select Editorials & Exclusive Interviews As featured at TheDailyBell.com

Free Download

High
Alert

How the Internet Reformation is causing a financial hurricane - and how to profit from it

Free Download

The Liberation
of Flockhead

A modest, monetary fable

Free Download

Who We Are

The Daily Bell is published by a dedicated team of experienced researchers and writers who utilize Anthony Wile’s VESTS model to analyze sociopolitical, economic and financial information from a free-market perspective, debunking mainstream media memes and providing insights and analysis derived from business cycle analysis that yield timely insights into profitable investment trends.

 
Sign Up for our FREE Newsletter

Subscribe now to start your FREE email subscription to
The Daily Bell Newswire.